Janice Campbell Founding Member of the National Association of Independent Writers and Editors
  • Home
  • Professional Profile
  • Speaker Information
  • HIRE ME!

Is Elitism At the Root of the Pronunciation War?

April 23, 2009 Post a comment

I just read an intriguing article by Russell Smith, writing for The Globe and Mail. In “You say KILLameeter, I say kil-OM-ater,” Smith suggests that “Anger over pronunciations usually hides a deeper anger at something else: the creeping influence of a culture or a class. It very much worries people when a common vulgarism or lower-class pronunciation becomes the accepted one.”

He may be right about this, as well as in his belief about the inevitability of the triumph of popular pronunciation due to the fact that “people with educations in language are far outnumbered by people without.” His pragmatic conclusion is that enforced pronunciation of kilometer is unlikely to further the cause of clear communication, so he declines to join the cause.

I understand the pragmatic point of view, but as a logophile, I also understand the distress over inconsistency and a loss of parallelism. Precision, like innocence, once abandoned is gone forever.

Categories: Words

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Recent Posts

  • The Hobbit Turns 80
  • Time Management Strategies for Freelancers and Entrepreneurs
  • Illumination: More than Just an Illustration
  • Famous Authors Insulting One Another’s Work
  • Ten Rules for Writing First Drafts

Monthly Digest

Blogroll

  • Doing What Matters
  • Everyday Education
  • Excellence in Literature

Meta

  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.org

Latest Posts

The Hobbit Turns 80

October 10, 2017

Time Management Strategies for Freelancers and Entrepreneurs

January 10, 2017

Illumination: More than Just an Illustration

July 26, 2016

Famous Authors Insulting One Another’s Work

July 25, 2014

Ten Rules for Writing First Drafts

September 10, 2013

Start Planning for Summer Reading

April 17, 2013

Contact Us

  • 804-476-4484
  • P.O. Box 412
    Montpelier, VA 23192-0412
Facebook Instagram Linkedin twitter

© NAIWE. All rights reserved. Designed by My House of Design.